| Year | Award | Ceremony | Nomination | Movie |
|---|
| 2017 | Golden Globe | Golden Globes, USA | Best Performance by an Actor in a Motion Picture - Drama | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2017 | AACTA International Award | AACTA International Awards | Best Lead Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2017 | EDA Award | Alliance of Women Film Journalists | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2017 | GFCA Award | Georgia Film Critics Association (GFCA) | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2017 | IFC Award | Iowa Film Critics Awards | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2017 | NSFC Award | National Society of Film Critics Awards, USA | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2017 | NCFCA Award | North Carolina Film Critics Association | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2017 | NTFCA Award | North Texas Film Critics Association, US | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2017 | OFCC Award | Oklahoma Film Critics Circle Awards | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2017 | OFCS Award | Online Film Critics Society Awards | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2017 | Desert Palm Achievement Award | Palm Springs International Film Festival | | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2017 | Cinema Vanguard Award | Santa Barbara International Film Festival | | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2017 | Seattle Film Critics Award | Seattle Film Critics Awards | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2017 | VFCC Award | Vancouver Film Critics Circle | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | AFCS Award | Atlanta Film Critics Society Awards | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | Austin Film Critics Award | Austin Film Critics Association | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | BOFCA Award | Boston Online Film Critics Association | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | BSFC Award | Boston Society of Film Critics Awards | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | Critics Choice Award | Broadcast Film Critics Association Awards | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | CFCA Award | Chicago Film Critics Association Awards | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | DFWFCA Award | Dallas-Fort Worth Film Critics Association Awards | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | DFCS Award | Detroit Film Critic Society, US | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | FFCC Award | Florida Film Critics Circle Awards | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | AISGE Award | Gijón International Film Festival | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | Gotham Independent Film Award | Gotham Awards | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | IFJA Award | Indiana Film Journalists Association, US | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | ICP Award | Indiewire Critics' Poll | Best Lead Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | KCFCC Award | Kansas City Film Critics Circle Awards | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | Sierra Award | Las Vegas Film Critics Society Awards | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | NBR Award | National Board of Review, USA | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | NFCS Award | Nevada Film Critics Society | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | NYFCC Award | New York Film Critics Circle Awards | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | NYFCO Award | New York Film Critics, Online | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | PCC Award | Phoenix Critics Circle | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | PFCS Award | Phoenix Film Critics Society Awards | Best Actor in a Leading Role | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | SDFCS Award | San Diego Film Critics Society Awards | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | SEFCA Award | Southeastern Film Critics Association Awards | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | SLFCA Award | St. Louis Film Critics Association, US | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | UFCA Award | Utah Film Critics Association Awards | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | VVFP Award | Village Voice Film Poll | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | WAFCA Award | Washington DC Area Film Critics Association Awards | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2016 | WFCC Award | Women Film Critics Circle Awards | Best Actor | Manchester by the Sea (2016) |
| 2010 | Biografilm Award | Venice Film Festival | Documentary | I'm Still Here (2010) |
| 2008 | ICS Award | International Cinephile Society Awards | Best Supporting Actor | The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford (2007) |
| 2008 | NSFC Award | National Society of Film Critics Awards, USA | Best Supporting Actor | The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford (2007) |
| 2008 | Prism Award | Prism Awards | Performance in a Feature Film | Gone Baby Gone (2007) |
| 2008 | Virtuoso Award | Santa Barbara International Film Festival | | Gone Baby Gone (2007) |
| 2007 | Hollywood Breakthrough Award | Hollywood Film Awards | Breakthrough Actor of the Year | |
| 2007 | NBR Award | National Board of Review, USA | Best Supporting Actor | The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford (2007) |
| 2007 | SFFCC Award | San Francisco Film Critics Circle | Best Supporting Actor | The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford (2007) |
| 2007 | Satellite Award | Satellite Awards | Best Actor in a Supporting Role, Drama | The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford (2007) |
| 2007 | SLFCA Award | St. Louis Film Critics Association, US | Best Supporting Actor | The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford (2007) |
ncG1vNJzZmimlanEsL7Toaeoq6RjvLOzjpyYrJ2pYq6nssuemqRlnprBbsPOq6uhZw%3D%3D